JollyPop Newborn vs JollyPop Pacifier PLUS: Age Guide
By RaZbaby - Home of the Keep it Kleen Pacifier and RaZ-Berry Teether | Published: 2026-10-13
Category: Comparisons
Compare JollyPop Newborn 0-3m and JollyPop PLUS 3m+ on size, color, and price. Learn how to choose the right pacifier size by age and when to switch.
Quick answer
For a newborn 0–3 months, choose the JollyPop Pacifier Newborn 0-3m. For babies 3 months and older, switch to the JollyPop Pacifier PLUS 3m+. Both share the same soft 100% silicone build, natural nipple shape, and one-piece design. The only real differences are the labeled age size and the color: blue for the newborn, teal or blue for the PLUS.
What actually changes between the two JollyPop pacifiers
Look past the color and you’ll find that the JollyPop Newborn 0-3m and the JollyPop Pacifier PLUS 3m+ are built on the same platform. Both are made of safe 100% silicone, have a soft and flexible body with no hard inner guard, and feature the same natural, textured nipple shape that babies already know from hospital baby bottles, Soothie, and Gumdrop. Both are unscented, phthalate-free, latex-free, BPA-free, DEHP-free, and one piece. The difference is the labeled age range and the color options: the newborn comes in blue, while the PLUS comes in teal and blue. That means your decision is mostly about size and stage, not material or shape.
How to tell when your baby is ready for the next size
The jump from 0–3m to 3m+ is not a hard deadline, but a guideline. Watch for these signs that your baby may be ready for the larger size: the pacifier looks small in their mouth, they chew or gnaw on it more than they suck, or they seem to lose suction and get frustrated. If none of those happen, there is no rush. If you are unsure, it is fine to offer the next size for a few minutes and see how your baby responds. Never force a pacifier if your baby refuses it.
Color, price, and everyday practicality
The newborn pacifier is blue, and the PLUS comes in teal or blue. If you want to color-code by stage—say, blue for newborn and teal for 3m+—the PLUS in teal gives you a clear visual cue. Price is close: the newborn is listed at USD 4.19 (compared to USD 5.99), and the PLUS teal at USD 3.95 (compared to USD 5.99) or PLUS blue at USD 4.13 (compared to USD 5.99). All three have a loop-shaped handle with nubs that is easy for small hands to hold and for you to attach a clip. Because they are one piece, there are no separate parts to lose or clean around.
Trade-offs to weigh
- Size vs. longevity: The newborn 0-3m is sized for the smallest mouths, but your baby will outgrow it. The PLUS 3m+ lasts longer but may be too large for a very small newborn. Start with the newborn size if your baby is under 3 months; buy the PLUS when you see signs of readiness.
- Color as a system: The newborn comes only in blue. The PLUS comes in teal or blue. Using teal for 3m+ gives you a quick visual check that you have the right size in the drawer. If you like color-coding, choose PLUS in teal for the older stage.
- Price and value: All three are close in price: newborn USD 4.19, PLUS teal USD 3.95, PLUS blue USD 4.13 (each compared to USD 5.99). The lower price on the PLUS teal is a small bonus, but do not let it override size. Pick the size that fits your baby’s stage first; the price difference is minor.
Product facts
- JollyPop Pacifier Newborn | 0-3m | Blue: JollyPop Pacifier Newborn | 0-3m | Blue: safe 100% silicone, soft and flexible with no hard inner guard, natural textured nipple shape like hospital bottles, Soothie and Gumdrop, unscented, phthalate-free, latex-free, BPA-free, DEHP-free, one piece. This is the size-matched option for newborns, with the same familiar nipple shape many babies already accept from the hospital.
- JollyPop Pacifier PLUS | 3m+ | Teal: JollyPop Pacifier PLUS | 3m+ | Teal: same silicone build and natural nipple shape, but labeled for 3 months and older; teal color. The teal color makes it easy to separate the older-baby pacifier from the newborn one, and the 3m+ label matches the next developmental stage.
- JollyPop Pacifier PLUS | 3m+ | Blue: JollyPop Pacifier PLUS | 3m+ | Blue: same features as the teal PLUS but in blue. If you prefer blue for both stages, you can still size up without changing color.
Which JollyPop should you choose?
Best for
- Newborns 0–3 months who need a size-matched pacifier
- Parents who want the same familiar nipple shape as hospital bottles, Soothie, or Gumdrop
- Babies who prefer a soft, flexible silicone pacifier with no hard inner guard
Not for
- Babies older than 3 months who show signs of needing a larger size — choose the JollyPop Pacifier PLUS 3m+ instead
- Babies who refuse silicone pacifiers or prefer a different nipple shape
- Parents looking for a pacifier with a hard shield or multiple pieces
