JollyPop Pacifier PLUS 3m+ vs Newborn: Sizing and Use Guide
By RaZbaby - Home of the Keep it Kleen Pacifier and RaZ-Berry Teether | Published: 2026-10-16
Category: Comparisons
Compare JollyPop Pacifier PLUS 3m+ and Newborn 0-3m on fit, safety, and when to size up. Includes a practical JollyPop size guide for parents.
Quick answer
Choose the JollyPop Newborn 0-3m for babies under three months, and switch to the JollyPop Pacifier PLUS 3m+ once your baby passes the three-month mark or shows signs of outgrowing the newborn size. Both share the same soft silicone build and natural nipple shape, so the main decision is age and fit, not material. If you want a pacifier that stays clean when dropped, consider the keep-it-kleen option as a separate, complementary choice.
What actually differs between the two JollyPop sizes
The JollyPop Pacifier PLUS 3m+ and the JollyPop Newborn 0-3m use the same 100% silicone construction, soft and flexible body with no hard inner guard, and a curved shape that fits baby's face. Both have a natural, textured nipple designed to feel like hospital baby bottles, Soothie, and Gumdrop, and both come from the inventor of Soothie and Gumdrop. They are also both phthalate-free, latex-free, BPA-free, and DEHP-free, and each is a one-piece design. The difference is the intended age range: Newborn is labeled 0-3m, while PLUS is labeled 3m+. That age label is your primary sizing signal.
How to tell when your baby is ready to size up
Watch for changes in how your baby uses the pacifier rather than relying only on the calendar. If the newborn pacifier starts slipping out more often, if your baby seems to work harder to keep it in, or if feeding and sleep routines change around the three-month mark, that is a practical cue to try the 3m+ size. Because both JollyPop options share the same nipple shape and soft silicone feel, the transition is usually about fit and retention, not a dramatic change in texture or firmness. If your baby was born early, use corrected age as a guide and check with your pediatrician about the right time to switch.
Color and pack choices for each size
The JollyPop Pacifier PLUS 3m+ comes in Pink, and the JollyPop Newborn 0-3m is available in Pink and Teal. All options are unscented and use two-tone baby bright colors. If you are stocking up, buying the same size in multiple colors can help you keep one at home, one in the diaper bag, and one at a caregiver's house without mixing sizes. If you want a pacifier that closes when dropped to keep the nipple clean, the keep-it-kleen Pacifier 2PK in Penguin & Bear is a different product line with a different mechanism, so treat it as a separate purchase rather than a size variant of JollyPop.
Trade-offs to weigh before you choose
- Age fit vs. long-term use: Newborn 0-3m is sized for the earliest weeks, so it may be outgrown relatively quickly. PLUS 3m+ is designed for a longer stretch of use but is not the right starting size for a newborn. Start with Newborn if your baby is under three months, then plan to move to PLUS.
- Same design vs. different size label: Both sizes share the same silicone, nipple shape, and soft body, so the choice comes down to the age label and how well the pacifier stays in your baby's mouth. If the newborn size keeps falling out, try the 3m+ size before assuming your baby no longer wants a pacifier.
- Cleanliness on the go vs. size selection: JollyPop sizes do not include a self-closing shield. The keep-it-kleen pacifier closes when dropped, which is a different feature set aimed at keeping the nipple clean in cars, planes, and parks. Decide whether your main problem is size or cleanliness, then buy accordingly.
Product facts
- JollyPop Pacifier PLUS | 3m+ | Pink: JollyPop Pacifier PLUS | 3m+ | Pink: Safe 100% silicone, soft and flexible with no hard inner guard, curved shape fits baby's face, natural textured nipple same as hospital baby bottles, Soothie and Gumdrop, easy-to-hold loop shaped handle with nubs, unscented, two-tone baby bright colors, from the inventor of Soothie and Gumdrop, phthalate-free, latex-free, BPA-free, DEHP-free, one piece. This is the size to choose once your baby is past the newborn stage and needs a pacifier that stays comfortably in place during longer sleep stretches.
- JollyPop Pacifier Newborn | 0-3m | Pink: JollyPop Pacifier Newborn | 0-3m | Pink: Safe 100% silicone, soft and flexible with no hard inner guard, comfortable curved shape fits baby's face, natural shape textured nipple babies love, same as hospital baby bottles, Soothie and Gumdrop, easy-to-hold loop shaped handle with nubs, unscented, two-tone baby bright colors, from the inventor of Soothie and Gumdrop, phthalate-free, latex-free, BPA-free, DEHP-free, one piece. This is the appropriate starting size for newborns and young infants, and its shared design with the 3m+ version makes the later size-up transition simpler.
- keep-it-kleen Pacifier 2PK - Penguin & Bear: keep-it-kleen Pacifier 2PK - Penguin & Bear: automatically closing shields that close when falling to keep the nipple clean, shield wrapped in soft materials to be gentle on baby's sensitive skin, increased opening angle vs previous keep it kleen generations for more comfortable use. If clean-on-the-go is your priority, this is a different product line with a self-closing shield, not a JollyPop size option, so it solves a different problem.
Which size should you buy?
Best for
- Babies under three months who need a newborn-sized pacifier
- Parents who want the same soft silicone and nipple shape across sizes for an easier transition
Not for
- Babies who consistently keep the newborn size in and show no signs of outgrowing it
- Parents whose main concern is keeping the pacifier clean after drops, who should look at the keep-it-kleen line instead
