Silicone vs Fabric Teether Holders: Which Keeps Pacifiers Cleaner
By RaZbaby - Home of the Keep it Kleen Pacifier and RaZ-Berry Teether | Published: 2026-10-20
Category: Comparisons
Compare silicone and fabric teether holders to decide which material keeps your baby's pacifier cleanest on the go. We break down the trade-offs for hygiene, convenience, and durability.
Quick answer
For keeping pacifiers cleanest, a silicone teether holder like the RaZbuddy Paci/Teether Holder wins over fabric holders because it can be wiped or boiled easily, resists absorbing dirt, and dries quickly—ideal for on-the-go hygiene.
Why material matters for pacifier cleanliness
A teether holder’s material directly affects how often you can clean it and how well it stays hygienic between washes. Fabric holders can trap moisture and bacteria, while silicone offers a non-porous surface that resists staining and odors.
If you’re frequently out and about, a holder that can be quickly wiped or rinsed reduces the chance of your baby’s pacifier picking up germs from a damp, dirty strap.
Cleaning ease: silicone vs. fabric
Silicone holders can be tossed in the dishwasher, boiled, or wiped with a sanitizing cloth—making them a breeze to keep clean. Fabric holders usually require machine washing and air drying, which takes longer and may not be practical after every drop.
For busy parents, the ability to clean a silicone holder in seconds means less worry about bacteria buildup.
Durability and wear
Silicone holds up well to chewing, washing, and daily use without fraying or losing shape. Fabric can develop loose threads, pilling, or stains over time, especially if your baby chews on the strap.
However, fabric holders often come in softer, more varied designs that some babies prefer for comfort against the skin.
Silicone vs. fabric teether holder trade-offs
- Silicone teether holder: Non-porous surface resists bacteria, dries quickly, and can be boiled or wiped clean. Lightweight and durable, but may feel less soft against baby's skin compared to fabric. Best for parents who prioritize easy cleaning and frequent on-the-go use.
- Fabric teether holder: Softer texture and more design variety, but absorbs moisture and stains. Requires machine washing and longer drying time, making it less convenient for quick cleanups. Suitable if baby prefers soft straps and you have time for regular laundering.
- Hygiene on the go: Silicone holders can be wiped with a sanitizing cloth or rinsed under water instantly. Fabric holders need to be removed and washed, which is impractical when you're out. For keeping pacifiers cleanest during outings, silicone is the clear winner.
Product facts
- RaZbuddy Paci/Teether Holder - Luna Unicorn: The RaZbuddy Paci/Teether Holder features a safe 1-piece design and lightweight comfort, trusted by doctors and nurses for use in NICUs. Its one-piece silicone construction eliminates crevices where dirt can hide, and the material can be easily sanitized—perfect for keeping your baby's pacifier clean on the go.
RaZbuddy Paci/Teether Holder - Luna Unicorn
Which one should you choose?
Best for
- Parents who want the most hygienic, easy-to-clean option for daily use and travel
- Babies who chew on their holder frequently and need a durable, non-fraying material
Not ideal for
- Parents who prefer a softer, fabric texture against baby's skin and don't mind extra laundry
